A friend and I were recently finalists for a safety award. Neither of us won.
Afterwards, she shared a photo of us holding our hands in an L shape. A bit of humour between two people who have known each other for around a decade, supported one another through our work in safety, and happened to be sharing a moment of recognition.
For me, it was as much about friendship as the award.
The comments took the conversation somewhere else. There were observations about award season, professional ego and how much safety professionals seem to enjoy celebrating themselves. All while people continue to be killed and seriously harmed through work.
That last point deserves attention.
Any profession concerned with preventing harm should be prepared to examine itself. We should question our institutions, conferences, credentials and awards. Are we recognising meaningful contributions, or mostly recognising activity within the profession? Have we become a little too interested in ourselves?
But I struggled with the choice being presented: celebrate recognition or remain focused on preventing harm.
I think that’s a false choice.
Did being pleased for a friend, or acknowledging a little recognition ourselves, mean we were less concerned about people being harmed at work?
I don’t think so.
What were we actually recognising?
I’m hardly a detached observer. I was one of the finalists, and the post involved a friend.
Would I have read the comments differently if they were about someone I didn’t know? Possibly. I need to leave room for that.
What I saw in the photograph was friendship and mutual support. We’ve known each other through a fair bit of our professional lives, and here was an opportunity to acknowledge one another’s work.
That doesn’t mean everybody looking at the post would see the same thing. What we intend and what somebody else takes from it can be quite different.
We weren’t declaring victory. We were acknowledging a moment that mattered to us.
I’m comfortable with recognition being questioned. What I struggled with was the suggestion that celebrating it meant we had lost sight of why the work matters.
Work that doesn’t stay solved
I wonder whether part of the tension comes from how we think about safety.
We sometimes describe it as a sequence of things to get right. Identify the hazards, implement the controls, build capability, monitor performance. It sounds fairly orderly when we put it like that.
Work is often messier.
A procedure might describe the task, but not quite the circumstances someone finds themselves in. A control can be working while the conditions around it change. People adjust, work around constraints and respond to things that weren’t anticipated.
Some of those adjustments help. Others introduce problems. We don’t always know which is which at the time.
This is part of what I recognise in Brad Mayhew’s description of working in the DARC: conditions that are dynamic, ambiguous, risky and complex. It brings my attention back to the work people are actually doing, rather than only the arrangements we have put around it.
Craig Ashhurst and Valerie Brown’s writing on wicked problems has also shaped how I think about this. Not because every safety problem is wicked. Many aren’t. But their emphasis on bringing different perspectives and forms of knowledge to a problem, and continuing to work with it rather than expecting a neat technical resolution, resonates with quite a bit of safety practice.
It makes me question whether the broader work is ever really complete.
That doesn’t excuse ineffective practice or make preventable harm inevitable. We still need to ask whether something actually helped.
The question I’ve been coming back to is much simpler: Are we making things better, and how would we know?
When would recognition be allowed?
If continuing harm makes recognition inappropriate, what would need to happen before it became legitimate?
The last workplace fatality? The last serious injury? For how long, and across what boundary? One organisation? An industry? Everywhere?
I struggle to see where that leaves us.
Unfinished work is no excuse for ineffective practice. We should still ask what changed, for whom, and why we think something was an improvement.
But continuing harm doesn’t tell us that every contribution has failed.
Equally, an award doesn’t tell us that a contribution has succeeded.
We need to look more closely than that.
What recognition might make possible
An award tells us that a contribution has been recognised through a particular process. Whether that contribution actually made work safer is a different question.
That distinction matters.
Recognition can draw attention to work worth examining. Someone redesigned a task, improved a control or raised something that others had come to accept as normal. Maybe they kept going with an issue after most people had moved on.
I want us to notice that.
Some of this work involves challenging established practice. Questioning a procedure that has been around for years. Offering an interpretation people don’t particularly want to hear. Admitting that something we’ve invested in isn’t doing what we hoped.
What we acknowledge says something about what we value.
There’s also an opportunity to share what happened.
But I’d rather hear what actually happened than the cleaned-up success story.
Where did it get difficult? What had to change along the way? What still isn’t working?
That’s often the useful part. It gives somebody else enough of the reality to decide whether there’s anything in it for their own work.
And sometimes recognition is more personal than any of that.
Someone’s effort has been noticed. A colleague is pleased for them. Two friends get to share a moment after years of supporting each other.
I don’t think every expression of appreciation needs to carry the weight of the whole profession’s performance.
Awards deserve scrutiny
There’s plenty about safety awards that should be questioned.
What is the recognition actually based on? Does the process distinguish between a well-presented initiative and an improvement? What evidence is available? Whose account of the work has been included?
And who gets seen?
People doing quiet, sustained work close to operational risk may not have the time, support or inclination to prepare an award submission. People like me may have more opportunity to explain our work publicly.
That doesn’t make our work more important.
Commercial arrangements deserve scrutiny too, particularly where the purpose of recognition becomes difficult to separate from the business around it.
And we should be careful with our claims.
A new initiative isn’t necessarily an improvement. Innovation doesn’t establish effectiveness. Being able to tell a persuasive story about our work doesn’t mean the work became safer.
These are fair questions. Continuing harm should keep us asking them.
But I want those questions to help us judge contributions more carefully, rather than lead us to assume that no contribution can be worthwhile while harm continues.
Critiquing how we recognise good work is different from arguing that good work shouldn’t be recognised.
What I’m taking from it
I tried to stay out of most of the commentary. I did question the choice being presented between celebrating recognition and caring about preventing harm.
Looking back, I don’t want the way a criticism is expressed to become a reason for avoiding the question underneath it.
There were questions in the exchange worth sitting with.
What do awards recognise? Whose work receives attention? When does recognition become self-congratulation?
Someone can look at an award and see encouragement, appreciation and useful work being shared. Someone else can see commercialisation, professional status and misplaced attention.
What can each perspective help us notice?
That’s one reason the wicked-problem framing interests me. A different perspective doesn’t have to be something to defeat. It might show us something we weren’t seeing.
That asks something of me too.
We encourage organisations to make room for people to question assumptions, offer different views and admit uncertainty. We should probably examine whether our own professional conversations allow the same, especially when it’s our work, our colleagues or something we value being questioned.
Not always easy to do.
The exchange hasn’t left me thinking awards should be beyond criticism. It has made me more interested in what we recognise, what that recognition tells us and whose contribution we might be missing.
It has also reminded me that being involved gives me a perspective.
It doesn’t give me the only one.
Progress can be real without being sufficient.
What matters is whether recognition leaves room for the questions that should follow it.
What changed? How do we know? What can others learn? What still needs attention?
I think we should be able to celebrate a worthwhile contribution and still ask all of those questions.